Coinbase FOIA Release Unveils SEC’s Internal Deliberations on XRP and Ethereum

By: fxcryptonews|2025/05/08 18:30:02
0
Share
copy
Coinbase FOIA Release Unveils SEC’s Internal Deliberations on XRP and Ethereum Coinbase has released a batch of internal documents obtained through Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, offering a rare glimpse into the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) evolving views on the regulatory status of XRP and Ethereum (ETH). The documents span communications from 2021 to 2023, reveal inconsistencies, internal doubts, and political pressure during the SEC’s high-profile legal battle with Ripple Labs and parallel investigations involving Ethereum. SEC Staff Question XRP’s Security Characteristics One of the most revealing disclosures stems from internal emails exchanged in 2021, where SEC staffers openly questioned whether XRP exhibits characteristics typical of securities. In one exchange, staff considered bringing in an expert to assess how the XRP Ledger (XRPL) would be affected if Ripple ceased operations. This hypothetical implies doubt over XRP’s dependency on Ripple, a key factor in applying the Howey Test. In a more formal tone, the SEC expressed its stance in a letter dated December 9, 2021, referring to XRP explicitly as a security. The letter criticised Ripple for launching its Liquidity Hub without consulting the SEC for guidance regarding securities law compliance. The SEC warned that Ripple might be offering XRP and other securities through the platform, either directly or indirectly. Two weeks later, Ripple responded, calling the claim “confounding” and asserting that the SEC is not its prudential regulator. Ripple also argued that engaging with the SEC often invites enforcement action, referencing the agency’s litigation history. Background: Ripple vs. SEC Legal Battle These documents surfaced amid Ripple’s legal standoff with the SEC, which began in December 2020. The SEC alleged that Ripple conducted an unregistered securities offering, raising $1.3 billion through XRP sales. Ripple vehemently denied the claim, stating that XRP is not a security and operates independently of Ripple’s activities. After years of back-and-forth litigation, a New York federal court ruled in favor of Ripple, stating that XRP itself is not a security. The ruling dealt a significant blow to the SEC’s case, casting doubt on its regulatory strategy toward digital assets. Related article: Ripple CLO: No Clear Crypto Laws Drove SEC to Drop Legal Fight New York AG Pressures SEC to Label Ethereum a Security The FOIA documents also uncover fresh insight into Ethereum’s regulatory status. In June 2023, Shimso Maswoswe, head of the New York Attorney General’s Investor Protection Bureau, emailed the SEC requesting the agency to file an amicus brief supporting New York’s position that Ethereum is a security. This request came three months after New York’s Attorney General sued KuCoin, accusing the exchange of allowing users to trade unregistered securities and commodities, including ETH. Maswoswe argued that SEC support in the form of an amicus brief would bolster the AG’s case and improve investor protection. While KuCoin eventually settled with New York, agreeing to cease operations in the state and pay a $28 million fine, the SEC’s investigation into Ethereum continued. The ongoing scrutiny prompted Ethereum software firm ConsenSys to sue the SEC, aiming to block any classification of ETH as a security. However, the SEC quietly dropped the investigation after approving multiple spot Ethereum ETFs, signalling an informal shift in its stance on Ethereum’s classification. Disclaimer: The information in this article should not be considered financial advice, and FXCryptoNews articles are intended only to provide educational and general information. Please consult with a financial advisor before making any investment decisions. Share this : On the networks Recent Articles Home Quizzes Videos Categories Newsletters Crypto News Currencies Useful links Coins Keep Exploring Crypto News

-- Price

--

You may also like

Morning Report | BitMine increased its holdings by 126,971 ETH last week; trader Eugene announced his exit from the crypto market

Overview of Important Market Events on June 8th

Wang Chuan: How can one not feel anxious after the neighbor Old Wang made thirty times profit by investing in storage stocks? (Seven) - A quarter-century cycle

In-depth analysis of the "reflexivity" bubble trap in storage stocks: Beware of the backlash from the bullwhip effect and the false narrative of high growth; do not let the short-term myth of wealth become a wealth abyss that cannot be recovered for 25 years.

Cryptocurrency CEXs are flocking to sell US stocks, and traditional brokerages are facing an "uninvited guest."

The major reshuffle has just begun.

$75 billion in foreign capital has fled, and South Korean retail investors have absorbed it all using leverage

Despite the accelerated migration of Korean funds from cryptocurrency to the stock market, the Korean market remains an important barometer for global cryptocurrency retail liquidity and recovery turning points.

Japan’s Three Megabanks Plan Joint Stablecoin Issuance in Fiscal 2026

MUFG, SMBC, and Mizuho reportedly plan to jointly issue fiat-pegged stablecoins in fiscal 2026, signaling Japan’s growing push into bank-led digital payment infrastructure.

Humanity Discloses H Token Dual-Chain Attack Details, With Losses on Ethereum and BSC Exceeding $36 Million

Humanity said the H token attack across Ethereum and BSC caused more than $36 million in losses after leaked ProxyAdmin keys enabled malicious contract upgrades and token minting.

Contents

Popular coins

Latest Crypto News

Read more
iconiconiconiconiconiconicon
Customer Support:@weikecs
Business Cooperation:@weikecs
Quant Trading & MM:bd@weex.com
VIP Program:support@weex.com